Explaining Professional Expertise in Strength and Conditioning: A New Foundation for the Profession
IUSCA Position Statement 2026 | Part 1 of 2
What does it truly mean to be a competent Strength and Conditioning practitioner? How should professional expertise be understood, developed, assessed and recognised?
These questions are fundamental to the future of the Strength and Conditioning (S&C) profession. They influence how practitioners are educated, how scientific research informs practice, how professional qualifications are awarded and how standards of competence are established internationally.
The International Universities Strength and Conditioning Association (IUSCA) has published a major Position Statement in the International Journal of Strength and Conditioning:
Explaining Professional Expertise in Strength and Conditioning: An IUSCA Position Statement on the International Qualification Framework (IQF) Level Descriptors.
Co-authored by an international group of experienced practitioners, researchers and academics, the publication establishes a philosophical and scientific foundation for understanding professional expertise and progression within S&C.
Grounded in realism and critical rationalism, the statement examines the relationship between scientific knowledge, professional judgement, practical capability and the continual identification and correction of error.
The implications extend across S&C education, practitioner development, research, certification, assessment and professional standards.
In this first article of a two-part series, we explore the foundational arguments of the Position Statement and their significance for the profession.
1. The Problem: How Should We Understand Professional Competence?
Strength and Conditioning has developed considerably over recent decades. The profession has benefited from expanding scientific research, increasingly sophisticated technologies, improved educational opportunities and greater recognition within high-performance sport.
However, important questions remain about how professional competence should be understood and evaluated.
A common assumption is that better practitioners are primarily those who possess more scientific knowledge, have read more research, accumulated more experience or mastered a greater number of established training methods.
While knowledge, experience and technical skills are essential, none independently guarantees effective professional practice.
Consider two athletes presenting with similar performance limitations. Despite comparable testing results, their underlying physical characteristics, training histories, competitive demands and environmental circumstances may differ substantially.
A practitioner cannot necessarily determine the most appropriate intervention simply by selecting a method supported by published research.
They must first identify and define the relevant problem, consider possible explanations, evaluate the available evidence and determine an appropriate course of action.
They must then implement that intervention, monitor its consequences and revise their approach where necessary.
Professional competence therefore involves the effective use of knowledge to solve problems within real-world contexts.
This distinction has important implications for professional education and assessment.
If competence is understood primarily as the possession of information or the reproduction of established methods, educational programmes and certifications may fail to capture the capabilities required for independent professional practice.
Similarly, if professional progression is defined largely through accumulated experience or additional qualifications, it may inadequately distinguish between practitioners operating at different levels of autonomy, responsibility and complexity.
The IUSCA Position Statement addresses these challenges by establishing a more comprehensive account of professional expertise.

2. The Institutional Position: Realism and Critical Rationalism
The Position Statement adopts realism and critical rationalism as its philosophical foundations.
These commitments establish how IUSCA understands scientific knowledge, professional practice and the development of expertise.
Realism: Understanding and Influencing an Objective Reality
Realism begins with the recognition that an objective reality exists independently of our beliefs, interpretations or theoretical models.
Within S&C, practitioners work with real physical systems governed by biological and physical principles.
Athletes respond to training interventions through underlying physiological, neurological, biomechanical and other causal processes.
Although these systems may be complex, variable and difficult to predict, they remain, in principle, open to scientific understanding and influence.
Our explanations may be incomplete or mistaken, but this does not mean that reality itself is arbitrary.
This provides an important foundation for scientific practice.
Practitioners can develop increasingly accurate explanations of physical performance, identify meaningful problems and design interventions intended to produce specific outcomes.
Critical Rationalism: Knowledge Develops Through Error Correction
Critical rationalism recognises that human knowledge is always provisional and capable of containing error.
Scientific progress therefore depends upon developing possible explanations and subjecting them to criticism, logical reasoning and empirical scrutiny.
Rather than treating research findings, established methods or professional consensus as final authorities, practitioners should remain willing to question and revise their understanding.
This approach emphasises several commitments:
Logic and reason.
Empirical scrutiny.
Scepticism towards authority.
Transparency.
Continual identification and correction of error.
These principles are particularly relevant to a profession in which scientific knowledge is continually developing and practitioners must make decisions under conditions of uncertainty.
A training method may be effective in one context and less effective in another. A widely accepted explanation may subsequently be challenged by stronger evidence or a better theoretical account.
Professional expertise consequently requires the capacity to recognise limitations, evaluate competing explanations and revise decisions when appropriate.
No method, model, authority or consensus provides final epistemic authority.
Importantly, this philosophical position is itself open to criticism and revision.

3. Five Foundational Principles of Strength and Conditioning Practice
The Position Statement identifies five foundational principles that help explain the nature and purpose of S&C practice.
Principle 1: There Is an Objective and Potentially Comprehensible Reality
The physical world exists independently of our understanding of it.
Through observation, testing, criticism and scientific investigation, practitioners can develop progressively better explanations of the systems with which they work.
Principle 2: Strength and Conditioning Concerns Physical Systems That Can Be Understood and Influenced
Athletes are biological systems governed by physical principles.
Although their responses may be complex and variable, appropriate interventions can influence relevant characteristics and performance outcomes.
Principle 3: Strength and Conditioning Can Be Understood Through Problems to Be Solved
Professional practice begins by identifying meaningful problems and desired outcomes.
These may concern physical performance, rehabilitation, injury risk, preparation for competition or longer-term athlete development.
The practitioner's responsibility is to define the problem accurately and determine how it might be addressed.
Principle 4: Better Knowledge Enables Better Solutions
More accurate and comprehensive explanations provide practitioners with greater opportunities to develop effective interventions.
Scientific progress expands the range of problems that can be understood and the potential solutions available.
Principle 5: Error Is Inevitable and Must Be Continually Identified and Corrected
All professional knowledge, decisions and interventions are fallible.
Progress depends upon recognising discrepancies between expectations and outcomes, investigating possible explanations and refining subsequent practice.
Together, these principles establish S&C as the systematic application of knowledge to physical systems to solve problems, grounded in objective reality and advanced through continual error correction.
They also position professional practice as an iterative process of inquiry, implementation, evaluation and improvement.

4. Defining Science, Knowledge and the Scientific Practitioner
A central contribution of the Position Statement is the clarification of concepts that are frequently used within S&C but not always consistently defined.
What Is Science?
Science is understood as a systematic approach to understanding reality through conjecture, logical reasoning, empirical evidence and criticism.
Scientific explanations are developed and scrutinised so that errors can be identified and corrected over time.
This understanding emphasises the explanatory and critical functions of science.
Research findings remain indispensable, but scientific practice also involves evaluating the reasoning, assumptions and explanations through which those findings are interpreted.
What Is a Scientific Practitioner?
A scientific practitioner applies science as a systematic approach to professional problem-solving.
They identify practical problems, develop possible explanations and solutions through reasoning grounded in relevant scientific principles, and use research evidence to constrain and refine those explanations.
This requires more than familiarity with scientific literature.
Practitioners must understand how scientific knowledge relates to the particular problems they encounter and how that understanding can inform effective action.
What Is Knowledge?
The Position Statement adopts a broad understanding of knowledge.
Knowledge includes information, understanding or capability with explanatory or practical significance.
It may be propositional, procedural or embodied in forms that are not yet fully represented through language.
This is particularly important in S&C, where professional expertise includes capabilities such as observing movement, recognising meaningful patterns, communicating effectively, demonstrating techniques and adjusting coaching interventions.
Some of these capabilities can be described through written explanations, while others are demonstrated primarily through professional action.
Professional progression therefore concerns the development and increasingly effective use of knowledge in this broader sense.


5. The Importance of Explanation in Professional Practice
One of the most significant arguments developed within the Position Statement concerns the value of explanatory knowledge.
Scientific research frequently identifies relationships between variables.
For example, research may demonstrate that athletes with greater relative squat strength tend to achieve faster sprint performances.
Such findings can provide useful information.
However, an observed association does not independently establish that increasing squat strength will necessarily improve sprint performance in every athlete.
To make an informed professional decision, the practitioner must consider why the relationship might exist.
Relevant explanations could involve force production capabilities, force-velocity characteristics, impulse, coordination, movement mechanics and the specific demands of sprinting.
The practitioner must also consider the characteristics and circumstances of the individual athlete.
An athlete whose sprint performance is limited by insufficient force production may require a different intervention from one whose primary limitation concerns coordination or technical execution.
This illustrates the distinction between identifying an empirical relationship and developing an explanation with broader practical application.
Explanatory knowledge expands the range of possible solutions available to practitioners.
It allows them to develop, test and refine interventions for problems and circumstances that may not have been examined directly within published research.
This does not diminish the importance of empirical evidence.
Research remains essential for scrutinising explanations, identifying errors and improving professional understanding.
However, the practical value of research depends partly upon the explanations through which findings are interpreted and applied.

6. Practitioner Knowledge Extends Beyond Written Information
Professional expertise cannot be fully represented through examinations of theoretical knowledge alone.
An experienced practitioner may demonstrate considerable capability in observing athletes, recognising relevant problems, communicating instructions and adapting interventions during training.
These capabilities may be informed by scientific knowledge without being fully expressible as written propositions.
The Position Statement recognises that practitioner knowledge can be expressed through several forms:
Scientific concepts and explanations.
Written programmes, frameworks and tools.
Communication and practical demonstration.
Perceptual, cognitive and motor capabilities.
Organisational processes and professional environments.
Effective practice integrates these forms of knowledge within an ongoing problem-solving process.
A practitioner identifies a problem, develops possible explanations, designs an intervention, implements the intervention and evaluates the results.
Feedback, criticism and reflection inform subsequent decisions.
This process is recursive rather than strictly linear.
New observations may require the original problem to be reconsidered. An intervention may reveal limitations in the practitioner's explanation. Changes in the athlete's circumstances may require a different approach.
Expertise involves what practitioners can perceive, explain, implement, monitor and revise within context.
This has substantial implications for how professional competence should be assessed.
Written examinations can evaluate important dimensions of scientific understanding, but practical coaching assessments, applied experience, professional portfolios and evidence of decision-making are also necessary to examine the broader capabilities involved in practice.

7. Complexity, Variability and Uncertainty in Strength and Conditioning
Athletes operate within complex systems involving physical, social and organisational influences.
Their responses to training may be nonlinear, variable and difficult to predict with precision.
Individual differences in physiology, training history, recovery, environmental circumstances and other relevant factors can influence the consequences of an intervention.
However, complexity does not imply the absence of underlying causal structure.
Nor does uncertainty mean that improved understanding is impossible.
Scientific explanations can become more accurate, and professional decisions can become more effective, even when perfect prediction remains unattainable.
Statistical and probabilistic models can support professional judgement by describing patterns, estimating uncertainty and informing expectations.
Nevertheless, such models do not independently replace causal explanation or the judgement required to interpret their relevance.
The practitioner remains responsible for integrating the available information.
They must determine which factors matter, evaluate competing explanations, select appropriate interventions and respond to emerging evidence.
The central integrative agent is the human practitioner, who defines the problem, judges relevance, interprets evidence and revises action.
This understanding reinforces the importance of autonomy, professional responsibility and critical thinking.
Uncertainty should encourage intellectual humility and continued inquiry while preserving the expectation that explanations and practical solutions can improve.

8. What Does This Mean for Professional Education and Standards?
The arguments developed in the Position Statement have important consequences for the future of S&C education and professional recognition.
Traditional educational and certification approaches frequently place substantial emphasis on the acquisition and recall of scientific information, established procedures and technical methods.
These remain important components of professional preparation.
However, a comprehensive approach to competence must also consider whether practitioners can use their knowledge effectively.
Can they identify and define meaningful problems?
Can they develop and critically evaluate explanations?
Can they exercise independent judgement when established methods do not adequately address the circumstances they encounter?
Can they implement interventions effectively, evaluate outcomes and correct errors?
Can they operate responsibly within increasingly complex professional environments?
These questions provide a more meaningful foundation for understanding professional progression.
They also inform the development of the IUSCA International Qualification Framework (IQF) Level Descriptors.
The IQF establishes a structured approach to recognising professional development through increasingly effective knowledge application, problem-solving, autonomy, responsibility, complexity management and error correction.
Within this approach, professional progression cannot be adequately understood simply through accumulating additional qualifications, learning more methods or completing more years of practice.
Instead, progression concerns the development of capabilities that enable practitioners to address increasingly demanding professional problems.
For universities and educational providers, this supports the integration of scientific understanding, practical experience, independent reasoning, coaching competence and professional reflection throughout educational programmes.
For certification and accreditation bodies, it provides a foundation for assessing professional competence through evidence that extends beyond theoretical examinations.
For employers and the wider profession, it offers a more coherent basis for understanding differences in professional responsibility, capability and expertise.
Ultimately, these principles contribute to a clearer and more defensible account of what it means to be a competent S&C professional.
Conclusion: Establishing a Foundation for the Future
The continued development of Strength and Conditioning as a recognised profession requires a coherent understanding of its purpose, scientific foundations and professional competencies.
The IUSCA Position Statement represents an important contribution to this development.
By adopting realism and critical rationalism, the publication establishes a philosophical foundation for understanding how professional knowledge develops, how practitioners solve problems and how expertise can be evaluated.
It recognises the indispensable contribution of scientific research while emphasising the explanatory knowledge, practical capability and professional judgement required to apply that research effectively.
It also establishes the importance of recognising and correcting error as a central feature of professional development.
These principles provide a foundation for more rigorous and meaningful approaches to S&C education, assessment, certification and professional standards.
The future of the profession depends upon developing practitioners who can think critically, explain effectively, act responsibly and continually improve their understanding and practice.
Coming Next: Part 2
In the second article of this series, we will examine how these philosophical and scientific foundations inform the development of the IUSCA International Qualification Framework (IQF) Level Descriptors.
We will explore the methodology underpinning the framework, the competencies associated with professional progression and the implications for education, practitioner certification, assessment and professional recognition internationally.
Read the Full Position Statement
Explaining Professional Expertise in Strength and Conditioning: An IUSCA Position Statement on the International Qualification Framework (IQF) Level Descriptors
Published in the International Journal of Strength and Conditioning.
Diamond Open Access. Free to read and share.







